The Tempest Comparing The Cultures In The

Tempest And Ours Essay, Research Paper

The Tempest: Comparing The Cultures in The Tempest and Ours

“All men are created equal” is one of the declarations that American

culture is built on. This declaration means that all men no matter of race,

religion, or creed are equals in the eyes of society, as well as the law. This

was not always true in history, especially not in Shakespeare’s day and age.

During this time, society had levels of classification where men were considered

“superior” to other men. Shakespeare gives us a taste of this hierarchical

culture through his play The Tempest. He shows us how “superior” men perceived

themselves in contrast to lesser beings due to their race, financial status, and

gender. We also are shown those who had reason to feel superior yet treated

others equally and with the respect due to them.

The Tempest reflects Shakespeare’s society through the relationship

between characters, especially between Prospero and Caliban. Caliban, who was

the previous king of the island, is taught how to be “civilized” by Prospero and

his daughter Miranda. Then he is forced to be their servant. Caliban explains

“Thou strok’st me and make much of me; wouldst give me Water with berries in ?t;

and teach me how to name the bigger light, how the less, That burn by day and

night; and then I lov’d thee, And show’d thee all the qualities o’ th’ isle,…

For I am all the subjects you have, which first was mine own king.”(I,ii,334-

354). We see he is treated as a lesser being because he is not of the same race

as Prospero and Miranda. Prospero describes him as “A freckled whelp hag-born -

not honour’d with a human shape.”(I,ii,282-283) Clearly, the people of different

races were treated as inferior human beings in Shakespeare’s time. In this

culture, because someone is different, they are less of a human than you.

Financial status also plays a major role in social classifications.

During the time of The Tempest, Dukes and Earls, who were among the nobles, were

considered to be superior even to other members of their own race. The nobles

had servants and commoners who worked for them. Shakespeare shows us an example

of this with the relationship between his characters of Sebastian and Antonio

and of the Boatswain and the sailors. Sebastian yells at the sailors “A pox o’

your throat, you bawling, blasphemous, incharitable dog!”(I,i,40-41), implying

that they are inferior and are there to serve him. Antonio also shows he

believes himself superior by stating to the Boatswain “Hang, cur! Hang, you

whoresom, insolent, noise-maker. We are less afraid to be drowned than thou

art.”(I,i,43-45) These men were of the same skin color, hair texture, and eye

color, but were treated inferior due to their financial status and “inferior”

blood line.

Women had also fallen victim to this hierarchial society. During this

era women were considered to be objects and were treated as property.

Shakespeare presents this in the treatment of Claribel, daughter of Alonso, and

Miranda by their fathers. Claribel was married of to the King of Tunis, an

African nation, merely for the gain of Alonso, the Duke of Milan, and his Lords.

Their feelings are clear in Sebastian’s words “Twas a sweet marriage, and we

prosper well in our return.” (II,i,69). And for Miranda, Prospero show how he

considers his only daughter as he states “Then, as my gift, and thine own

acquisition Worthily purcas’d, take my daughter…”(IV,i,13-14) She is obviously

considered his property. Women did not have rights at this time and were merely

used as pawns in trade with other men of stature to gain whatever it was they

wished.

Not all men in the position to consider themselves superior thought

themselves to be. Even though some men had the financial status or noble blood,

they treated others equally and genuinely thought them equal. Ferdinand,

although being the Prince of Naples, treats Miranda, who he thinks a mere maid,

as an equal human being deserving nothing less than his affection and kindness.

This is proven true in his conversation with Miranda where he tells her “O, if a

virgin, And your affection not gone forth, I’ll make you the Queen of

Naples.”(I,ii,450-452). He loves her and would have her as his wife and Queen

even though he thinks her a mere maid. Gonzalo also shows us his heart when he

sees Ariel enter with the Boatswain and sailors. He refers to them as “here is

more of us” (V,i,15) showing he considers the Boatswain and sailors his equal.

In these two characters, Shakespeare is saying that not all men are egotistical

and perceive themselves above others.

From being treated inferior, people start to believe themselves inferior.

From being unjustly treated, Caliban thinks himself inferior to Prospero’s race.

When Stepheno and Triniculo arrived on the island, Caliban considered them

superior beings even though they were mere servants themselves. They also

thought themselves superior to Caliban because he was of a different race even

though Caliban does prove to have a greater intellect than both Stepheno and

Triniculo. We see their sense of superiority by how they refer to Caliban

“Servant-Monster, drink to me”(III,ii,3). Caliban also shows us his acceptance

of this treatment in his response “How do thy honour? Let me lick thy

shoe…”(III,ii,22-23) and “Thou shalt be lord of it, and I’ll serve

thee”(III,ii,56). We see by this that Caliban truly believes himself inferior

even though his own intellect surpasses that of Stepheno and Triniculo. In

today’s society, treatment of inferiority is against the law and supposedly non-

existent openly in society. We all know, however, that this hierarchial mind

set still lurks around every corner in today’s culture. It may not go as far as

forcing someone to be your servant, but it lives in the form of discrimination

and segregation. Because of many years of inferior treatment, many people feel

they either can not succeed or that it will be more difficult for them than

those of the “right” race or financial bracket. It is not that the people today

feel inferior, its that they feel they will not get a fair chance. It’s

commonly believed that the people of “inferior” races or monetary status will

get picked over for jobs or other discriminatory acts will be performed against

them.

The two cultures are quite different, but they also have some slight

similarities. Our culture is over three-hundred years older than that of

Shakespeare, which should make our society more mature in its actions and

attitude. We should have learned that all men truly are equal and should be

treated accordingly. But all three-hundred years has taught us was how to be

more discreet in our actions and feelings by giving them pretty names or keeping

them out of the public eye. These two cultures may appear very different but

actually are a lot closer than most of society would have us believe.